hermes-agent/optional-skills/creative/creative-ideation/references/methods/chance-and-remix.md
SHL0MS d799284b15
feat(optional-skills/creative-ideation): expand to v2.1.0 method library (#42402)
The optional-skills copy was still the v1.0.0 constraint-dispatch skill
(SKILL.md + full-prompt-library.md only). This brings it up to the current
tool: a situation-routed library of 22 named ideation methods drawn from
working artists, scientists, designers, and writers.

SKILL.md becomes a 4-step router (extract PHASE/DOMAIN/SPECIFICITY signals
→ apply overrides → route phase-then-domain → resolve ambiguity), with
anti-slop operating rules and an anti-default check.

Adds:
- 22 method files under references/methods/ — oblique-strategies (Eno/Schmidt),
  oulipo, scamper, lateral-provocations (de Bono), triz (Altshuller),
  leverage-points (Meadows), pattern-languages (Alexander), compression-progress
  (Schmidhuber), analogy-and-blending, pataphysics, first-principles, polya,
  biomimicry, volume-generation, creative-discipline, premortem-and-inversion,
  defamiliarization, derive-and-mapping, affinity-diagrams, jobs-to-be-done,
  story-skeletons, chance-and-remix. Each: when/when-not, the actual
  cards/principles/operators, a procedure, a worked example, anti-slop notes.
- references/method-catalog.md (index + when-to-use), heuristics.md (extended
  decision tree), anti-slop.md (rules applied to every output), exercises.md
  (time-boxed exercises).
- full-prompt-library.md restructured into domain-affinity sections (general /
  software / physical / social / lists) so the no-direction default isn't
  developer-biased.

Frontmatter: name aligned to directory slug (creative-ideation, folding in
the fix from #18084); version 2.0.0→2.1.0; platforms field preserved.

Original wttdotm-derived constraint dispatch is kept as the default path.
Supersedes #19295 (which targeted the pre-move skills/ path).

Co-authored-by: SHL0MS <[email protected]>
2026-06-19 15:40:02 -07:00

3.7 KiB
Raw Permalink Blame History

Chance and Remix

Four traditions of surrendering authorial control to procedure:

  • Surrealist exquisite corpse — Breton et al., 1925. Folded-paper collaborative writing/drawing.
  • John Cage's chance operations — Music of Changes (1951). Composed via I Ching coin tosses.
  • Burroughs–Gysin cut-up — Minutes to Go (1960). Cut existing text, rearrange.
  • Situationist détournement — Debord & Wolman, 1956. Re-edit existing media to subvert original meaning.

When to use

  • Existing material feels exhausted; need new structure from same material
  • Stuck inside an authorial voice
  • Want to interrupt your own taste (Cage: your taste is what limits the work)
  • Producing experimental work
  • Subverting source material (détournement)

Don't use when

  • You need linear coherence and argument
  • Audience requires polish (cut-edges and discontinuities are usually visible)
  • Source material has copyright issues you can't navigate
  • Using "chance" as alibi for sloppiness (real chance procedures are strict)

Exquisite corpse

Surrealists, 1925, rue du Château apartment. The name comes from the first sentence: "Le cadavre exquis boira le vin nouveau".

Procedure: 3+ participants. First writes a sentence fragment, folds the paper to hide it, passes. Second sees only the last few words and continues. Repeat. Unfold at end.

Variants: drawings (head/torso/legs in three folds), single-author asynchronous (write, hide for a day, write next), distributed by chat or mail.

Cage chance operations

Procedure:

  1. Define what gets randomized (pitch, duration, dynamics, tempo).
  2. Pick a chance device (coin tosses, dice, RNG, I Ching).
  3. Let the device determine the parameters.
  4. Notate / build / perform the result.
  5. Use what comes out. Overriding for taste defeats the operation.

Variants: time-bracket scores (Cage's late practice — windows within which sounds occur). Algorithmic chance (script-driven). Generative systems (Eno's Music for Airports, Reflection).

Cut-up technique

Gysin, Beat Hotel Paris, 1959. Bowie used it for Diamond Dogs, Heroes, Outside. Thom Yorke for Kid A.

Procedure:

  1. Take a page of existing text — your own draft, a newspaper, a manual, anything.
  2. Cut into fragments — by line, phrase, or word.
  3. Shuffle.
  4. Reassemble. Don't force coherence; use the new juxtapositions.
  5. Use the strongest combinations as starting points.

Variants: fold-in (Burroughs — fold one page over another). Voice cut-ups (tape splice). Algorithmic cut-up (script).

Détournement

Debord & Wolman, 1956. Take an existing piece of media and re-edit / re-caption / re-purpose to invert its meaning. The political stakes are explicit: dominant-culture critique using its own materials.

Procedure:

  1. Select source material whose meaning you want to invert.
  2. Identify the minimum modification that produces the subversion. (Power comes from recognizability of the source.)
  3. Apply: re-caption, re-edit, re-frame, re-context.
  4. Distribute.

Examples: Debord's La Société du spectacle film (1973) is largely détourned feature footage with new voiceover. May 1968 Paris graffiti détourned advertising copy. Adbusters subvertising tradition.

Anti-slop notes

  • "Generate randomly" without a specified procedure is slop. State what is randomized, by what mechanism.
  • Don't generate cut-up text by guessing what cut-up sounds like. Run the actual procedure on real text.
  • Don't romanticize. The procedures are specific.
  • Détournement requires a target. Generic "subversive remixes" without specific source-and-target are vibe.

Sources: Cage, Silence (Wesleyan, 1961); Burroughs & Gysin, The Third Mind (Viking, 1978); Debord & Wolman, "Mode d'emploi du détournement" (Les Lèvres Nues 8, 1956).